DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MS. CLARK
MS. CLARK: MR. FENJVES, DIRECTING YOUR ATTENTION TO THE DATE OF JUNE THE 12TH, 1994, AS OF THAT DATE, CAN YOU TELL US APPROXIMATELY WHERE YOU LIVED?
MR. FENJVES: I LIVED IN THE 800 BLOCK OF SOUTH GRETA GREEN.
MS. CLARK: WHERE IS THAT IN RELATIONSHIP TO 875 SOUTH BUNDY?
******
MR. FENJVES: WE SHARE A COMMON BACK ALLEY AND I'MABOUT 60 OR 70 YARDS NORTH OF THE CONDO OF NICOLE SIMPSON BROWN.
******
MS. CLARK: NOW, WHAT PORTION OF YOUR APARTMENT FACES THAT ALLEY?
MR. FENJVES: IT'S A THREE-STORY BUILDING AND THE TOP FLOOR IS THE MASTER BEDROOM WHICH FACES THE ALLEY, THEN THERE'S A KITCHEN, AND BELOW THAT, I HAVE MY OFFICE, AND THAT'S PRETTY MUCH SEALED OFF AND YOU CAN'T SEE OUT INTO THE ALLEY.
MS. CLARK: IF YOU LOOK OUT YOUR MASTER BEDROOM, ARE YOU ABLE TO SEE THE BACK OF 875 SOUTH BUNDY?
MR. FENJVES: I'M ABLE TO SEE THE -- WHAT SEEMS TO BE A PORCH AREA AND A ROW OF WINDOWS ALONG THE TOP FLOOR, BUT THAT'S ABOUT ALL I CAN SEE.
******
MS. CLARK: DID YOU KNOW NICOLE BROWN, SIR?
MR. FENJVES: NO, I DID NOT.
MS. CLARK: HAD YOU SEEN HER BEFORE?
MR. FENJVES: JUST IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. WE HAD A SIMILAR JOGGING ROUTE AND I HAD SEEN HER IN HER CAR PULLING INTO THE ALLEY ONCE OR TWICE. THAT WAS ABOUT IT.
MS. CLARK: DID YOU HAPPEN TO -- DID YOU KNOW WHERE SHE LIVED BACK IN JUNE OF 1994?
MR. FENJVES: NO, I DIDN'T KNOW WHERE SHE LIVED AND I DIDN'T KNOW WHO SHE WAS.
MS. CLARK: ON JUNE THE 12TH OF 1994, SIR, IN THE EVENING, WHERE WERE YOU?
MR. FENJVES: AT 10:00 O'CLOCK THAT EVENING, I WAS WATCHING THE NEWS IN THE MASTER BEDROOM ON THE THIRD FLOOR WITH MY WIFE.
MS. CLARK: THAT'S THE MASTER BEDROOM THAT –
MR. FENJVES: FACES THE --
MS. CLARK: -- FACES THE ALLEY THAT YOU SHARE WITH 875 SOUTH BUNDY?
MR. FENJVES: THAT IS CORRECT.
******
MS. CLARK: AND FOR HOW LONG DID YOU WATCH THE NEWS?
MR. FENJVES: WELL, ABOUT 15 OR 20 MINUTES INTO IT, I BECAME AWARE OF A BARKING SOUND AND THEN I PROBABLY STOPPED WATCHING THE NEWS SHORTLY THEREAFTER.
MS. CLARK: SO IT WAS APPROXIMATELY 15 MINUTES AFTER THE NEWS BEGAN THAT YOU STARTED TO HEAR A DOG BARKING?
MR. FENJVES: YES.
MR. COCHRAN: WELL, YOUR HONOR, THAT MISSTATES WHAT HE JUST SAID, 15 TO 20 MINUTES.
THE COURT: MISS CLARK?
MS. CLARK: TELL US –
MR. FENJVES: 15, 20 MINUTES INTO IT, I HEARD A VERY DISTINCTIVE BARKING COMING FROM SOMEWHERE TO THE SOUTH OF WHERE I LIVE AND I WAS AWARE OF IT FOR MAYBE FIVE, SIX, SEVEN MINUTES; AND AT THAT POINT, I STOPPED WATCHING THE NEWS AND I LEFT THE MASTER BEDROOM.
MS. CLARK: WAS THERE SOMETHING UNUSUAL ABOUT THAT DOG BARKING THAT DREW YOUR ATTENTION TO IT?
MR. FENJVES: IT WAS A -- YOU KNOW, IT WAS FAIRLY PERSISTENT, IT WAS AT A SIGNIFICANT PITCH, AND AS YOU MAY RECALL, I DESCRIBED IT AT THE TIME AS A PLAINTIVE WAIL. SOUNDED LIKE A, YOU KNOW, VERY UNHAPPY ANIMAL.
******
MS. CLARK: AND THAT'S WHAT DREW YOUR ATTENTION?
MR FENJVES: YES, IT DID.
MS. CLARK: HAD YOU EVER HEARD DOGS BARKING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD BEFORE?
MR. FENJVES: YEAH, THERE'S PLENTY OF DOGS BARKING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD, BUT THIS WAS, AS I SAID, PERSISTENT AND UNUSUAL AND UNHAPPY.
MS. CLARK: SO DID YOU STAY AND LISTEN TO THE BARKING FOR A WHILE BEFORE YOU WENT DOWNSTAIRS?
MR. FENJVES: UH, NO. I DON'T RECALL WHETHER I WENT AND LOOKED -- I BELIEVE I MAY HAVE GOTTEN UP AND LOOKED THROUGH THE SHUTTERS, AND THEN I JUST -- I WENT DOWNSTAIRS TO MY OFFICE.
MS. CLARK: ABOUT WHAT TIME WAS IT WHEN YOU WENT DOWNSTAIRS TO YOUR OFFICE?
MR. FENJVES: I'D SAY AROUND 10:20.
MS. CLARK: AND BY THAT TIME, YOU HAD HEARD THE DOG BARKING FOR HOW LONG?
MR. FENJVES: AS I SAID, YOU KNOW, IT COULD HAVE BEEN FIVE MINUTES. IT COULD HAVE BEEN SEVEN, EIGHT MINUTES.
******
MS. CLARK: AT THE TIME THAT YOU FIRST HEARD THE DOG BARKING, COULD YOU TELL FROM WHAT DIRECTION IT SEEMED TO BE COMING?
MR. FENJVES: YES. IT SEEMED TO BE COMING FROM THE -- BASICALLY THE AREA, SOUTH CORNER OF DOROTHY AND BUNDY.
******
MS. CLARK: AND WHEN YOU CAME BACK UPSTAIRS AT 11:00 O'CLOCK, WAS THE BARKING STILL AUDIBLE?
MR. FENJVES: YES, IT WAS.
MS. CLARK: WHERE DID YOU GO WHEN YOU CAME UPSTAIRS AT 11:00 O'CLOCK?
MR. FENJVES: I GOT IN BED.
MS. CLARK: AND WHEN YOU GOT IN BED, WAS THE DOG STILL BARKING?
MR. FENJVES: YES, HE WAS.
MS. CLARK: WHAT DID YOU DO AT THAT POINT?
MR. FENJVES: I WAS READING FOR A LITTLE WHILE. I MENTIONED TO MY WIFE THAT, YOU KNOW, I WAS CONCERNED ABOUT THE DOG.
UMM, OUR OWN DOG WAS ON THE BED AND HE WAS REACTING TO THE BARKING BY GROWLING A LITTLE BIT, AND I MAY HAVE -- I THINK I WENT BACK AND TOOK ANOTHER LOOK THROUGH THE SHUTTERS AND I NOTICED THE LINE OF WINDOWS AT THE RESIDENCE. AND WAS A LIGHT ON AND I ASSUMED THAT SOMEBODY WAS HOME.
AND THERE WERE A LOT OF UNITS AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE MAP THAT WERE CLOSER TO THE SOUND. SO I THOUGHT SOMEBODY MAY HAVE ALREADY DONE SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
MS. CLARK: SO YOU FELT THAT THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN SOMETHING WRONG, BUT SOMEONE ELSE MAY HAVE REPORTED IT ALREADY?
MR. FENJVES: UMM, IT WAS -- YOU KNOW, IT WAS HARD TO INTERPRET WHAT WAS GOING ON. THE DOG DIDN'T SOUND AS THOUGH IT WAS IN PAIN OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT. IT SOUNDED, AS I SAID, UNHAPPY.
******
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR. COCHRAN
MR. COCHRAN: YOU ARE NOT -- YOU ARE A DOG OWNER; IS THAT CORRECT?
MR. FENJVES: THAT'S RIGHT.
MR. COCHRAN: AND AS SUCH, I PRESUME YOU'VE OWNED A DOG FOR SOME NUMBER OF YEARS?
MR FENJVES: A COUPLE OF YEARS, YEAH.
MR. COCHRAN: YOU'RE NOT AN EXPERT IN DOGS BARKING AS SUCH, ARE YOU?
MR. FENJVES: NO, SIR. I DO NOT PRETEND TO BE.
MR. COCHRAN: AND YOU CAN'T TELL PARTICULAR PEDIGREE OF A DOG, ONE DOG OVER ANOTHER WHEN THEY BARK, CAN YOU?
MR. FENJVES: NO, I CAN NOT, SIR.
MR. COCHRAN: AND AS I UNDERSTAND IT, YOU NEVER AT ANY TIME THAT NIGHT SAW A DOG?
MR. FENJVES: I DID NOT SEE A DOG.
******